Posts Tagged ‘Georgia’

Bans on court use of sharia/international law: 33 bills in 20 states to start 2012; review of all efforts since 2010

January 30th, 2012

2012 marks the third year in a row to see major legislative efforts to ban state courts from using sharia or international law. A recap:

2010

Write up of all 2010 efforts here

2010 saw three efforts make their way out of their respective legislatures. The Oklahoma constitutional amendment would never take force, having been struck down by a federal district court, a determination upheld by the Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit in January 2012.

  • Louisiana HB 785 & SB 460: “Foreign law” means any law, rule, or legal code or system established and used or applied in a jurisdiction outside of the states or territories of the United States…A court, arbitrator, administrative agency, or other adjudicative, mediation, or enforcement authority shall not enforce a foreign law if doing so would violate a right guaranteed by the constitution of this state or of the United States.
  • Oklahoma HJR 1056 (Constitutional Amendment): Prohibits the courts to “look to the legal precepts of other nations or cultures. Specifically, the courts shall not consider Sharia Law or international law.” Requires courts adhere only to the U.S. & Oklahoma Constitutions, federal and state law and regulations, and where necessary the laws and regulations of another state.
  • Tennessee HB 3768 & SB 3740: Defines “law, legal code, or legal system” means a law, legal code, or legal system used or applied in any jurisdiction outside of Tennessee, including any foreign state, jurisdiction, country or territory of the United States…Notwithstanding any law to the contrary, and subject to provisions of superseding federal treaties, any otherwise enforceable contract which incorporates any substantive or procedural law, legal code or legal system of another state, foreign jurisdiction or foreign country that would violate rights and privileges granted under the United States or Tennessee Constitution is declared to be against public policy of this state and is unenforceable in this state.

2011

Write up of all 2011 efforts here

Despite having far more bills introduced in 2011 than in 2010, there was only one such piece of legislation enacted

  • Arizona HB 2064 Defines “foreign law” as “any law, rule or legal code or system other than the constitution, laws and ratified treaties of the united states and the territories of the united states, or the constitution and laws of this state….a court, arbitrator, administrative agency or other adjudicative, mediation or enforcement authority shall not enforce a foreign law if doing so would violate a right guaranteed by the constitution of this state or of the united states or conflict with the laws of the united states or of this state.”

2012

15 sharia/international law bans were carried over from the 2011 session. Combined with 18 newly introduced bills this puts the issue front and center for the 2012 sessions. Already there has been activity, with the Florida Senate Judiciary Committee giving its approval to a ban.

Full roster of 33 bills introduced in 2012 in 20 states and their statuses after the jump.

Prefiled bills in Georgia and Missouri look to change races for judgeships and clerks of court into nonpartisan contests

December 16th, 2011

2011 saw an influx of bills to move judicial and clerk of court races from partisan to nonpartisan, with arguments advanced both for and against the proposition. 2012 is already looking to pick up exactly where those debates left off.

Under Georgia’s HB 682 of 2012, elections for Clerks of the Superior Court, District Attorneys, and similar county-level officers would become nonpartisan. Similar bills have all died in committee in the last several years (HB 88 and HB 130  of 2009; SB 464 of 2010).

Missouri’s efforts at transitioning its judicial elections to nonpartisan have fared better. Although famous for the use and creation of merit selection (often called the “Missouri plan”), not every county in the Show Me State actually uses the merit selection for Circuit Court judgeships. SB 525 of 2012 would require all such races not already covered by the merit selection system to be nonpartisan, as well as prohibiting the judges from certain partisan activities. The bill is identical to SB 225 of 2011 which was approved by the Senate Financial and Government Organization and Elections Committee in February 2011.

Bans on court use of sharia/international law: Pennsylvania bill introduced

November 28th, 2011

Welcome New York Times readers!

Welcome Post-Gazette readers!

Since the last update of this list in October, one piece of legislation has been introduced.  Pennsylvania’s HB 2029 bans court references to any “foreign legal code or system” if doing so would impair constitutional rights.

Full roster of 2010 bills are available. 2011 and 2012 bills after the jump. » Read more: Bans on court use of sharia/international law: Pennsylvania bill introduced

2011 Southern court interpreters legislation

November 8th, 2011

Law

Georgia HB 24 Substantially revises, supersedes, and modernizes provisions relating to evidence. Modifies existing state laws with respect to foreign language in the courts. Provides Supreme Court to set rules and requirements for foreign language interpreters. Specifies Supreme Court may establish fees to be paid for certification.

Texas HB 2249 / SB 652 ORIGINAL: Extends licensed court interpreter advisory board until 2019. ENACTED: Extends licensed court interpreter advisory board until 2017.

Texas HB 2945 / SB 1233 Allows court in a county that borders Mexico or the Gulf of Mexico to appoint a language interpreter who is not a licensed court interpreter.

Approved by one chamber

Florida HB 7199 Creates Supreme Court of Civil Appeals and Supreme Court of Criminal Appeals as panels of the state’s Supreme Court. Assigns Supreme Court of Civil Appeals responsibility to set standards for court interpreters. Approved by full House. Killed in Senate committee.

Texas SB 286 Provides that, if after examining the proposed ward’s assets the court determines the proposed ward is unable to pay for costs allocated to the proposed ward under this section, the county is responsible for those costs, including an interpreter. Approved by full Senate. Died in House committee.

Died in committee

North Carolina SB 132 Provides if a party or witness in court does not speak or understand the English language, the cost of interpreting or translating services for the party or witness is payable from funds appropriated to the Judicial Department. Provides where individual is indigent, the Administrative Office of the Courts and the Office of Indigent Defense Services may enter into a memorandum of understanding for the payment of interpreting and translating services. Provides except in cases of indigence, Administrative Office of the Courts not obligated to bear the cost of interpreting or translating services for noncourt services and activities, such as discovery, trial, preparation, and attorney/client meetings.

Texas HB 331 Authorizes governing body of a municipality to create a municipal court equal justice and education fund, portions of which may be used for interpreter services. Requires certain defendants to pay court costs for deposit in the fund.

Texas HB 2250 Ends requirement licensed court interpreter advisory board be subject to sunset law.

Texas SB 220 ORIGINAL: Provides that, if after examining the proposed ward’s assets the court determines the proposed ward is unable to pay for costs allocated to the proposed ward under this section, the county is responsible for those costs, including an interpreter. AMENDED: Removal of reference to interpreters.

 

 

 

Bans on court use of sharia/international law: list of all bills since 2010, new 2011 Michigan bill, first 2012 bill prefiled

October 3rd, 2011

This post has been updated. Click here.

Since the last update of this list in August, two pieces of legislation have been introduced. Michigan’s SB 701 appears to be the Senate version of HB 4769, which has gone nowhere since its June introduction.

The other bill is Alabama SB 33 of 2012, a prefiled bill for the next session. SB 33 of 2012 is a constitutional amendment that looks more like HB 607 / SB 61 than HB 597 / SB 62 in that it does not specifically mention “sharia”.

It should be noted that at least some 2011 bills will make a return in 2012; roughly half of states allow bills to be “carried over” from one session to the next. Definitive answers as to which bills will return will be available as the legislatures come back into session in January.

Full roster of bills going back to 2010 after the jump.
» Read more: Bans on court use of sharia/international law: list of all bills since 2010, new 2011 Michigan bill, first 2012 bill prefiled

2011 South-Atlantic indigent defense legislation

September 13th, 2011

Law

Florida HB 7067 / SB 1016 / SB 7018 Re-creates Indigent Civil Defense Trust Fund within Justice Administrative Commission without modification. Repeals provisions that would have terminated the trust fund in 2012. (see also HB 7065 / SB 1014 / SB 7016)

Florida HB 443 / HB 7199 / SB 170 Requires that each public defender implement a system to electronically file court documents with the clerk of the court. Requires Florida Public Defender Association report to the President of the Senate and the Speaker of the House of Representatives by a specified date on the progress made in implementing the electronic filing system.

Georgia HB 238 Reconstitutes and vacates all currently serving members of the Georgia Public Defender Standards Council. Provides for appointing new members. Alters powers and duties of the council and council director, council’s responsibility to set policy and standards, and the director’s responsibility to develop rules and regulations to efficiently administer the provisions of the law related to public defenders. Provides director to appoint circuit public defenders and requires two-thirds vote of council to remove the chairperson of the council or to overturn the director’s decision regarding the removal of a circuit public defender. Requires certain annual reports be prepared by the director, rather than the council, and a copy sent to the Supreme Court.  Changes provisions relating to the circuit public defender supervisory panel. Changes provisions relating to appointing attorneys in conflict of interest cases.

Maryland SB 515 Specifies that an individual whose assets and net annual income are less than 100% of the federal poverty guidelines may be determined eligible for services from the Office of the Public Defender (OPD) without an assessment. Clarifies that the District Court, a Circuit Court, and the Court of Special Appeals are prohibited from appointing an attorney through OPD to represent an indigent individual if (1) there is a conflict in legal representation in a matter involving multiple defendants and one of the defendants is being represented by or through OPD; or (2) OPD declines to provide representation to an indigent individual entitled to representation.

North Carolina HB 243 Provides fee charged by clerk for certificates under seal is waived for appointed attorneys representing indigent clients.

Virginia SB 902 Permits retired justices or judges to appear as counsel in cases in courts of the Commonwealth if (i) the retired justice or judge has been retired for at least two years and is not authorized for temporary recall by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, (ii) the retired justice or judge is appearing as counsel, pro bono, for an indigent person in a civil matter, (iii) such civil matter is assigned or referred to the retired justice or judge by a nonprofit legal aid program organized under the auspices of the Virginia State Bar, and (iv) the retired justice or judge is not an employee, officer, or board member of such nonprofit legal aid program.

Active/Carried over into 2012

Georgia HB 648 Implements HR 977 (Constitutional Amendment). Creates trust fund for indigent defense dollars collected by clerks. Provides and specifies certain fees and assessments are dedicated to funding legal services for indigent persons accused of crimes and delinquent acts. Provides such funds are to be remitted to the Georgia Public Defender Standards Council.

Georgia HB 977 (Constitutional Amendment) Creates trust fund for indigent defense dollars collected by clerks. Provides and specifies certain fees and assessments are dedicated to funding legal services for indigent persons accused of crimes and delinquent acts.

Approved by one chamber

West Virginia HB 3067 / SB 549 Increases certain civil filings fees currently collected by circuit courts, and impose a new docketing fee for unspecified civil appeals including family court appeals but not including Workers’ Comp cases or, presumably, actions in the Supreme Courts original jurisdiction, to be collected by the Court and paid, at its discretion, to either Legal Aid of West Virginia (LAWV) or into the Interest on Lawyer’s Trust Accounts (IOLTA) fund. Approved by full House, died in Senate Finance Committee.

West Virginia SB 568 Clarifies that an attorney from the public defender office shall be appointed by a judge in all cases where an attorney-at-law is required to be appointed for an eligible client. Approved by full Senate, died in House Judiciary Committee.

West Virginia SCR 79 Requests Joint Committee on Government and Finance study need for authorizing executive director of Public Defender Services control over public defender corporations. Approved by full Senate, died in House.

Died in committee

North Carolina SB 596 Expands state’s office of public defender system to every county in state. Realigns public defender districts accordingly.

Virginia HB 1570 / SB 908 Increases from $10 to $14 fee on most civil actions filed in trial courts to pay for free civil legal representation provided for the poor by a nonprofit legal aid program organized under the auspices of the Virginia State Bar. Changes from $9 to $13 the amount that, from such additional fee, is to be credited to the Virginia State Bar’s Legal Aid Services Fund.

West Virginia SB 482 Requires public defender corporations of all the judicial circuits to be centralized under the executive director of Public Defender Services and grants executive director rulemaking authority.

State-by-State 2011 Legislative Year in Review: Georgia

August 29th, 2011

New laws affecting the courts enacted by the Georgia legislature in 2011 include the following:

HB 24 Substantially revises, supersedes, and modernizes provisions relating to evidence.

HB 41 Exempts the Department of Law from the fee charged for the preparation of the record in capital felony cases. Reduces per-page cost to prepare record on appeal from $10 to $1.50. Exempts issuance of certificates of appointment of notaries public from the judicial operations fund fee.

HB 158 Changes date for non-partisan elections, including judges, to June from July.

HB 265 Creates 2011 Special Council on Criminal Justice Reform for Georgians. Council to report to Chief Justice, Governor, Lieutenant Governor and Speaker of the House of Representatives by November 2011.

HB 266 Authorizes Magistrate Court Constables to carry firearms into courthouses and elsewhere in same manner as judges, police, etc.

HB 339 Revises the courts to which a challenge of a quarantine or vaccination order may be brought and manner of appealing orders concerning such challenges. Removes chief judge of the court of appeals’ power to declare judicial emergencies. Provides extensions of judicial emergencies by chief justice may only last as long as governor has declared state of emergency.

HB 415 Creates “modernized and uniform system of compiling, creating, maintaining, and updating jury lists.” Provides for state-wide compilation and distribution of the state-wide master jury list by the Council of Superior Court Clerks of Georgia. Eliminates forced balancing of county jury pools by race, gender, and ethnicity for the purpose of complying with the United States and Georgia Constitutions and the Unified Appeal process. Modernizes terminology relating to juries. Removes nonmechanical procedures relative to selecting persons for jury service. Changes eligibility requirements for grand jurors. Provides the Council of Superior Court Clerks of Georgia assist county boards of jury commissioners with jury matters. Provides for the methodology for county boards of jury commissioners to obtain county master jury lists. Prohibits public disclosure of jury source lists except under certain circumstances.

SB 30 Requires municipal court judges to be attorneys. Allows those non-attorney judges currently serving to continue in service. Provides any judge serving as of June 2011 may continue to serve.

SB 39 Permits creation of mental health court divisions in any court with criminal jurisdiction.

SB 47 Changes provisions relating to the composition and responsibilities of the Georgia Magistrate Courts Training Council.

Will Georgia become the sixth state to have a Tax Court within the judicial branch?

August 19th, 2011

Welcome TaxProf Blog readers!

A subcommittee of the Georgia House Judiciary (Civil) Committee will meet on August 24 to consider the creation of a Tax Court in the state. Under HB 100 of 2011 the court would be in place for 10 years as a pilot project and have concurrent jurisdiction with the Superior Court on matters related to the Department of Revenue. Unlike in many states which require constitutional amendments to create altogether new courts, the Georgia Constitution allows the legislature to create such pilot project courts, but requires a two-thirds vote for their creation (Article VI, Section I, Paragraph X).

Five other states have separate courts to handle such tax issues: trial-type or level courts in Arizona, New Jersey, Oklahoma, and Oregon and a specialized intermediate appellate court in Indiana. “Tax courts” in other states are executive branch or administrative agencies that perform quasi-judicial functions but are not formally parts of the judicial branch, such as in Maryland and Minnesota.

2011 South-Atlantic bail/pretrial release legislation

August 16th, 2011

Law

Florida HB 347 / SB 514 Requires defendant who was arrested for leaving scene of crash involving death to be held in custody until brought before judge for admittance to bail in certain circumstances.

Florida HB 575 / SB 844 Authorizes court, in determining whether to require or set amount of bail, to consider likelihood that person will be imprisoned for violation of probation or community control.

Maryland HB 682 / SB 809 Prohibits a court that exercises criminal jurisdiction from refunding a forfeiture of bail or collateral at a specified time unless a private surety pays a forfeiture of bail or collateral within a specified time period after a defendant’s failure to appear. Requires a court to refund a forfeiture of bail bond or collateral that was not paid within a specified time period after a defendant’s failure to appear under specified circumstances.

North Carolina HB 649 Amends laws pertaining to grounds for revocation of licensure regulating bail bondsman and allowing a bail agent on behalf of a surety company to make written motions setting aside bail forfeiture and relief from final judgment of bail forfeiture under laws pertaining the criminal procedure.

Virginia HB 1713 Adds to the list of crimes charged for which there is a presumption against admission to bail, subject to rebuttal, obstruction of justice where a person threatens bodily harm or force to knowingly attempt to intimidate or impede a witness.

Virginia HB 2060 Provides that a magistrate who is to set the terms of bail of a person arrested and brought before him pursuant to a capias shall, unless circumstances exist that require him to impose more restrictive terms of bail, set bail in accordance with the order of the court that issued the capias if such an order is affixed to or made a part of the capias by the court.

Virginia HB 2106  / SB 925 Allows GPS for persons on secured bond.

Virginia HB 2437 Provides that a licensed bail bondsman shall not charge less than 10 percent or more than 15 percent of the amount of the bond for a bail bond premium and shall not loan money with interest for the purpose of helping another obtain a bail bond. Defines bail bond premium as the amount of money paid to a licensed bail bondsman for the execution of a bail bond.

Introduced with committee and/or floor approval

Florida HB 1379 Provides that a defendant is eligible to receive government-funded pretrial release only by order of the court after the court finds in writing, upon consideration of the defendant’s affidavit of indigence: That the defendant is indigent or partially indigent as set forth in the Florida Rules of Criminal Procedure and that the defendant has not previously failed to appear at any required court proceeding. Prohibits defendants from participating in a pretrial release program if the defendant’s income is over 300 percent of the federal poverty guidelines prescribed for the size of the household of the defendant by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, unless the defendant is receiving certain financial assistance. Requires that defendants who seek to post a surety bond pursuant to a bond schedule established by administrative order as an alternative to government-funded pretrial release be permitted to do so without any interference or restriction by a pretrial release program. Requires pretrial release programs certify annually, in writing, to the chief circuit court judge, that the program has complied with the reporting requirements in current statutes.

Florida HB 265 Requires court considering whether to release defendant on bail to determine whether defendant is subject to registration as sexual offender or predator and, if so, to hold defendant without bail until first appearance on case.

Florida HB 7089 Requires a court, when determining whether to release a defendant on bail or other conditions, to consider the defendant’s legal residency status in the United States.

North Carolina SB 756 Revises laws related to pretrial release programs. Eliminates unsecured appearance bond as a pretrial release condition. Provides no state funds may be appropriated for the support of a pretrial release program.

South Carolina HB 3895 / SB 795 Provides that an appearance bond is valid for a certain time period in circuit and magistrates or municipal courts under certain circumstances. Provides a procedure to relieve the surety of liability when the time period has run.

Virginia HB 2332  Provides if judicial officer concurs in the determination of police officer that defendant is present in U.S. illegally and finds probable cause to believe that the person will not appear for trial or hearing, the judicial officer may refuse to admit the person to bail.

Introduced with committee rejection

Florida SB 372 Requires each pretrial release program established by ordinance of a county commission, by administrative order of a court, or by any other means in order to assist in the release of a defendant from pretrial custody to conform to the eligibility criteria set forth by the act. Preempts any conflicting local ordinances, orders, or practices. Requires that the defendant satisfy certain eligibility criteria in order to be assigned to a pretrial release program, etc

Florida SB 494 Requires a court considering whether to release a defendant on bail to determine whether the defendant is subject to registration as a sexual offender or predator and, if so, to hold the defendant without bail until the first appearance on the case.

Maryland HB 272 Requires, notwithstanding any other law or Maryland Rule, that a court or a District Court commissioner ask a defendant to provide information on the defendant’s legal status in the United States before the court or a District Court commissioner authorizes the defendant’s pretrial release on bail or personal recognizance. Authorizes the court or a District Court commissioner to consider the information on the defendant’s legal status in deciding whether to authorize the pretrial release of the defendant.

Maryland HB 1264 Prohibits a District Court commissioner from authorizing the pretrial release of a defendant charged with causing abuse or neglect of a vulnerable adult in the first or second degree.

Maryland HB 768 / SB 940 Allows a defendant in a circuit court or the District Court or a private surety acting for the defendant who posts a bail bond in an amount that is 10% of the penalty amount to deposit with the clerk of court half of the amount immediately and the other half within 6 months later.

Introduced with other or no activity

Georgia HB 32 Revises the requirements for releasing a person on his or her own recognizance.

Georgia HB 252 Add violations for which cash bonds can be accepted in lieu of bail and proceedings for failure to appear.

Georgia HB 288 Require as a condition of bail for certain offenses that DNA collection be performed on the person seeking bond.

Maryland HB 898 / SB 686 Provides that if a bail bondsman arranges to accept payment of a bail bond premium in installments, the installment agreement shall include information about the total premium amount owed, down payment made, and other terms of the installment contract. Requires that information about the bail bond premium installment payment agreement be included in an affidavit of surety. Requires bail bondsmen, if arranging bail bond premium installment agreements, to follow specified collection procedures.

North Carolina SB 740 Allows a bail agent on behalf of a surety company to make written motions setting aside bail forfeiture and relief from final judgment of bail forfeiture under laws pertaining the criminal procedure.

South Carolina SB 45 & SB 266 Provides Circuit Court to hear  motions regarding reconsideration of bond for general sessions offenses. Provides defense motions to reconsider may be heard by the circuit court only upon the defendant’s prima facie showing of a material change in circumstances.

South Carolina SB 267 Provides a person committing or attempting to commit a general sessions offense while on bail bond must be imprisoned five years in addition to the punishment for the principal offense.

West Virginia HB 2068 Provides certain specific statutory conditions of bond in cases involving crimes between family or household members in lieu of allowing the issuing authority to set conditions of bail.

Georgia House Judiciary Civil Committee to examine juvenile proceedings & open meetings and records

August 16th, 2011

Georgia’s House Judiciary Civil Committee is set to meet August 23, 24 and 25 to examine HB 641, a bill that would extensively rewrite the way court proceedings related to juveniles are handled in the state. The 230+ page bill purports to:

  • substantially revise, supersede, and modernize provisions relating to juvenile proceedings
  • provide for the Office of the Child Advocate for the Protection of Children
  • amend current law relating to children and youth services so as to provide for an appeal procedure when the Division of Family and Children Services of the Department of Human Services fails to provide aftercare and transitional services to certain children
  • provide for the Department of Human Services to provide for performance measures for an independent living skills program

When the committee finishes its work on that, it has set August 30 aside for a discussion of HB 397, a bill to revise the state’s open meetings and open records. The bill would:

  • comprehensively revise the provisions of law regarding open meetings and open records
  • provide definitions relating to open meetings
  • provide for open meetings, with exceptions and exemptions
  • provide for the manner of closing meeting
  • provide for remedies and sanctions for improperly closing meetings