Hearings in Maryland and Missouri tomorrow to change way states pick judges

Plans to change the way judges are picked in Maryland and Missouri are set for committee hearings tomorrow.

In Maryland, two bills previously debated over the last several sessions are returning to the House Judiciary Committee (2017 coverage here).

HB 513 of 2018

Former HB 579 of 2017, HB 388 of 2016, HB 1071 of 2015SB 295 of 2013, HB 1385 of 2010

Ends elections for Circuit Court judges. Provides judges to be appointed by governor, confirmed by senate, and subject to yes/no retention elections. Reduces term in office from 15 years down to 10 years.

HB 607 of 2018

Former HB 826 of 2017, HB 223 of 2016

Ends elections for Circuit Court judges. Provides Circuit Court judges to be appointed by governor and confirmed by senate. Provides if confirmation vote is less than 80% of senate, judge is subject to contested election. Provides judges who are 80% confirmed or who win contested elect are to be reappointed by governor at end of a 15 year term and need not be reconfirmed or face another retention election.

In Missouri the Senate Government Reform Committee will consider SJR 28. Currently the nominating commissions for the state’s appellate courts and select Circuit Courts must send “three persons” to the governor. SJR 8 eliminates the “three persons” language and replaces with “all qualified nominees and shall not be limited in number, but shall contain at least three nominees.” A version of the plan (SJR 11 of 2017) cleared the Senate General Laws Committee last year after the Senate leader indicated he may move to simply eliminate the merit/commission system entirely accusing the state’s supreme court of “going rogue” and his desire to see more conservatives on the bench.