Maryland: Last year Senate President vowed to end Circuit Court elections; bill to do just that up for hearing next week

Last year after a House plan to end elections for Maryland Circuit Court judges was killed in committee, Senate President Thomas V. Mike Miller vowed “We’re going to pass it next year.” The Senate has now released its 2016 plan as SB 179. It is set for a hearing next Thursday (February 4).

Currently the Maryland Constitution (Art. IV, Sec. 3) requires the election of Circuit Judges to 15 year terms. The general elections are nonpartisan, however candidates for Circuit Court appear on partisan primary ballots (such as these races in 2014).

The Senate plan calls for

  • The Governor to appoint anyone meeting the minimum criteria (over 30, admitted to practice of law, state resident 5 years, circuit resident for 6 months)
  • Senate confirmation
  • Serve for term of 10 years (down from the present 15 years) or until age 70 (if the judge hits the mandatory retirement age midterm)
  • Reappointment by Governor after 10 year term
  • Reconfirmation by Senate

The House version rejected last year would have kept 15 year terms and replaced reappointment/reconfirmation with yes/no retention elections.

SB 179 contemplates, but does not require, creation of a judicial nominating commission or similar body to make recommendations to the governor. If such a commission is created SB 179 calls for the group to “reflect the demographic diversity of the state or the judicial circuit.”