FL House Speaker wants to expand Supreme Court: Court packing plan, or merely a “reform”?

News reports coming out of Florida indicate there is an attempt underway to expand the state’s supreme court. House Speaker Dean Cannon announced earlier today he wants to increase the size of the Florida Supreme Court from seven to 10 members and divide the 10 member court into two, 5 -member panels (one civil, one criminal). Cannon denies this is a court packing effort, claiming instead he wants to “reform” the court.

The only two states that even approximate this proposal are Oklahoma and Texas, however these two states have entirely separate courts to handle civil (Supreme Court) and criminal (Court of Criminal Appeals) cases.

The Tallahassee Democrat noted that Speaker Cannon was irate last year when the state’s Supreme Court struck from the ballot several legislatively introduced initiatives. In his first speech as Speaker-designate in November 2010, Cannon went out of his way to attack the court’s decisions.

This wouldn’t be the first time a Florida Supreme Court decision prompted a legislative effort to increase the size of the court. In 2007, Florida state senator Bill Posey introduced SB 408 in 2007 to expand the state’s Supreme Court from 7 to 15 members. The bill’s text explicitly stated the reason for the increase was to overturn the Court’s decision in 2006 that found unconstitutional the state’s use of public money for vouchers for use in Catholic schools. (Bush v. Holmes, 919 So.2d 392 (Fla. 2006)) When SB 408 became public, the senator quickly withdrew it, telling the Tallahassee Democrat “Basically, a law student came up with the idea and asked me to have it drafted so he could see how it would look, but it was never supposed to be introduced.” The senator declined to identify the law student.

For a 2010 review of efforts to tinker with the size of the state supreme courts, read Issue 4:14 of Gavel to Gavel here. For the recent effort to increase the Arizona Supreme Court (without asking or talking with the state’s Chief Justice first), read this blog post.

Update: 3/7/11 @ 3:23 According to a Twitter feed coming out of the press conference where Cannon made these announcements, Senate President Mike Haridopolos says House Speaker Cannon idea on FL Supreme Court will be given fair consideration. (h/t Gary Fineout)